Status Briefing August 2005

From Scienticity

Jump to: navigation, search
m
Line 1: Line 1:
The publication by the Union of Concerned Scientists of its report on Scientific Integrity{{ref|ucs}}  early in 2004 was a significant event. The report was unusual for the depth and breadth of its documenting instances of the Bush Administration's overt politicization of the scientific process, particularly in public health, and in environmental and regulatory science. No doubt helped by the prominence of the scientists who first signed on to the "Restoring Scientific Integrity" statement, it dramatically increased the visibility of concerns about political abuses of science policy-making.
The publication by the Union of Concerned Scientists of its report on Scientific Integrity{{ref|ucs}}  early in 2004 was a significant event. The report was unusual for the depth and breadth of its documenting instances of the Bush Administration's overt politicization of the scientific process, particularly in public health, and in environmental and regulatory science. No doubt helped by the prominence of the scientists who first signed on to the "Restoring Scientific Integrity" statement, it dramatically increased the visibility of concerns about political abuses of science policy-making.
-
The report certainly got the attention of the White House. John H. Marburger III, director of the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy and chief science advisor to the President{{ref|mar1}}, issued an unprecedented twenty-page statement to Congress{{ref|mars}} on 2 April 2004 that was intended to refute the charges made in the UCS report.
+
The report certainly got the attention of the White House. John H. Marburger III, director of the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy and chief science advisor to the President{{ref|mar1}}, issued an unprecedented twenty-page statement to Congress{{ref|mar2}} on 2 April 2004 that was intended to refute the charges made in the UCS report.
Despite strong assertions about the commitment of the Bush administration to "applying the highest scientific standards in decision-making", Marburger failed to make credible rebuttals of the UCS charges. As just one example, he called the UCS assertion that the Bush Administration was suppressing important climate-change research "not true"; however, events since then, particularly the criticism of US policy made by several participants in the recent G8 summit, suggest that the original claim was, if anything, conservative.
Despite strong assertions about the commitment of the Bush administration to "applying the highest scientific standards in decision-making", Marburger failed to make credible rebuttals of the UCS charges. As just one example, he called the UCS assertion that the Bush Administration was suppressing important climate-change research "not true"; however, events since then, particularly the criticism of US policy made by several participants in the recent G8 summit, suggest that the original claim was, if anything, conservative.

Revision as of 05:32, 22 September 2005

Personal tools
science time-capsules